Skip to main content

The Marcos debate

I am glad, dear karikna, that my article which was printed last week (Loving Marcos as a right: In defense of historical revisionism) has sparked a fiery and intelligent debate at the Riknakem blog. The rich discourse generated in the space is a rarity in Marcos-related forums, where most comments usually go outside the bounds of good taste and civility.

Allow me to share with you select comments from both the Anti-Marcos and Pro-Marcos camps, and my final stance at the end of the day.

Anti -Marcos
jonathantobi: You spit on the memory of all martial law victims. The majority of those who suffered under the regime were not the communists and rebels.

Before Marcos took power, we were a center of innovation in Southeast Asia. Marcos and his cronies then plundered billions of dollars from our economy for their own benefit; US courts have awarded cases to thousands of Martial Law victims, and Marcos is recognized as the 2nd most corrupt dictator worldwide, in terms of plunders.

Alas, it then started the downfall of our economy, which his incompetent successors continued. Marcos was an affront to democracy, human rights, and freedom. To everything that the heroes of the revolution fought for, that we may live free today.

You, sir, and attempts to whitewash crimes like these, are part of the problem.

No to historical revisionism! #NeverAgain

iskramboldeggs: Herdy, look. Marcos was indeed a brilliant person, maybe one of the most intelligent and hard-working politicians the Philippines has ever seen. However, one thing you cannot overlook was his greed for wealth and for power. How can you explain the sudden opulence of their family during his regime? How can you explain the various Swiss bank accounts accredited to him not just by our NBI, but by the FBI and the Interpol? How else can you explain his rampant violation of our Constitution when he usurped the powers of Congress by giving himself legislative powers? How else can you explain his actions when he appointed his cronies to juicy positions both in the public and the private sectors? He was a brilliant man, but he turned his brilliance into amassing wealth and power for himself. 

Lean: What is foul is that you discredited the negative effects of the Marcos regime that outweighed all his positive contributions.

For how could you blame the people disillusioned by Marcos and his cronies’ looting of government institutions and Imelda’s extortive business behavior?

How could you blame the mothers weeping for their children who rallied for democracy but only ended up being tortured, raped, or killed?

How could you blame those who marched on the streets and believed that the state needed to change a government for the better?

And how dare you compare Marcos’s dictatorship to the likes of Lee Kuan Yew’s and Mahathir’s? Singapore and Malaysia are built upon the pillars of bureaucratic competence and elite autonomy. The Philippines is choked by patrimonialism and an underdeveloped government, all of which Marcos only aggravated. So, never compare as if authoritarianism should be appropriate for all states because they are all the same.

OK, let’s talk statistics. According to SWS, the highest poverty rate in the Philippines is 74% which was reported in April 1983. According NSCB, poverty rate spiked highest at 44% in June 1985. Guess the president during those periods.

Let me also make this clear: I am not pro-Aquino. Yet I believe that the grim consequences of bad dictatorship only prove that loving Marcos is a right, but not the right thing to do.

Pro-Marcos
ichinose kotomi: “You spit on the memory of all martial law victims.” How about the memories of those innocent farmers and innocent people from time of Cory? Let us not become Double Standard hypocrites. History tells that before Marcos, we were already suffering from major corruptions and from rebels. Don’t forget that only Marcos had the balls to give the rebels the punishment they deserved. History is meant to be revised, especially if it’s tainted with lies.

GERRY: Before Marcos assumed the presidency, his family was already one of the prominent families in the region. He was Major in the armed forces and his heroism was recognized not only by the Allied Forces but by the Japanese Army as well. He was a UP Law who topped the bar even when he reviewed inside a prison cell. Being a top lawyer, congressman, and senator, it’s not surprising that he accumulated wealth legally. What detractors assume is that the Marcos wealth all came from alleged plunder and corruption. Again, look at what he did to the country: his accomplishments on physical and human infrastructure are unequalled by any other president. Marcos borrowed only 10 billion dollars in his 20 year term. Can anyone give a figure how much we owe now?

peejhay: Those yellow historians who distort history are the awful ones. I may not have been born during the Marcos time but my parents and my grandparents witnessed that era. They always tell me how good the economy back then and that made their lives comfortably good. My relatives may not be historians, but I believe they tell true stories of the past.

Herdy’s closing statement
By imposing on our people what they should believe in and how they should feel about Marcos, these self-styled democracy fighters have unwittingly become the very dictator they abhor. At the end of the day, Marcos will continue to be seen in a better light by a vast majority of Filipinos, no matter what bashers say.

At any rate, let’s continue to agree to disagree freely and responsibly, always taking in mind that all of us are Filipinos who love our country as much as we love the truth we are altogether, through this vibrant sharing of thoughts, hoping to find.

Mabuhay.


herdylayumul.com

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Empanada festival: A celebration of good taste and good life

By Dominic B. dela Cruz & Leilanie G. Adriano Staff reporters BATAC CITY—If there is one thing Batac is truly proud of, it would be its famous empanada-making business that has nurtured its people over the years. Embracing a century-old culture and culinary tradition, Batac’s empanada claims to be the best and tastiest in the country with its distinctive Ilokano taste courtesy of its local ingredients: fresh grated papaya, mongo, chopped longganisa, and egg. The crispy orange wrapper and is made of rice flour that is deep-fried. The celebration of this city’s famous traditional fast food attracting locals and tourists elsewhere comes with the City Charter Day of Batac every 23 rd  of June. Every year, the City Government of Batac led by Mayor Jeffrey Jubal Nalupta commemorate the city’s charter day celebration to further promote its famous One-Town, One Product, the Batac empanada. Empanada City The Batac empanada festival has already become an annua

PIDS expert says income tax cuts justified; warns gov’t of revenue loss

Proposals to amend the personal income tax schedule appear to be well-justified. However, these proposals should include measures that will allow government to recover the revenue loss from lower income taxes. Dr. Rosario Manasan, senior research fellow of state think-tank Philippine Institute for Development Studies (PIDS), said at a seminar sponsored by the Philippine Senate, that government should look for new revenue measures to compensate for the projected revenue loss that will arise as a result of the implementation of any of the various proposals to restructure the personal income tax. Currently, there are several income tax reform proposals pending in both houses of Congress. All of them, according to Dr. Manasan, have the same objective of addressing the phenomenon of bracket creep, which results from “non-indexation to inflation of personal income tax brackets”. Simply put, bracket creep occurs when employees’ income increases over time as a result of inflation. Th

PGIN honors Ilocano heroes of past, present through Heroes Walk

SPO1 Allan Lampitoc Franco of Banna, Ilocos Norte and PO2 Jovalyn D. Lozano of Adams, Ilocos Norte receive a resolution of commendation, a certificate of college scholarship grant to their family members and a P20,000 cash incentive each from the Provincial Government of Ilocos Norte represented by Governor Imee R. Marcos and Vice Governor Angelo M. Barba in recognition of their bravery and heroic acts in the Mamasapano clash in Maguindanao on January 25. Mr. Franco and Mr. Lozano were recognized on March 10 in time for the unveiling of the second batch of Ilocano heroes at the Heroes Walk located along the Sirib Mile in Laoag City.  (Lei Adriano) By Jennifer T. Pambid PGIN-CMO In honor of the heroes who brought freedom, fame and glory to the province as well as to the country in the past century, the Provincial Government of Ilocos Norte (PGIN) through the Education Department and Sirib Youth Office launched the second batch of Ilocano Heroes Walk on March 10, 2015.